The Man

October 22, 2007 at 4:20 pm (Rants) (, , )

And sticking it to him. It’s a relatively quiet time for the industry, all the big trade shows have come and gone, the line up for Christmas is pretty much now set in stone and the gaming news networks are wondering how to fill all the space they have between now and the avalanche of holiday releases. So as it goes, when news isn’t happening, one must make it oneself.
A perpetual bogeyman for the industry has been the spectre of government interference and censorship. From time to time someone with an agenda will pop up and suggest that perhaps letting kids play games in which they have to chainsaw bits off their friends isn’t such a great idea. Occasionally something particularly sad will happen, some troubled individual will unleash all their confused teenage frustrations on their classmates and, people who should know better will triumphantly hold up a copy of the latest digital scapegoat and proclaim that all of said troubled individual’s issues stemmed from cutting bits off his digital friends with a digital chainsaw. Of course! It all seems so clear now. Except that of course that the history of messed up kids doing dumb things is much longer than the history of computer games – or violent movies or heavy metal music etc.

So the Jack Thompsons of this world get given their ten minutes of infamy to declaim on how things would be so much better if it weren’t for those damn video games. And the really messed up part? We give it to them. We the ‘gaming public’ validate them and give their viewpoints the exposure that they crave. I was prompted to write this when I saw a GU comic on the subject. Woody was linking to an initiative by the Videogame Voters Network to produce a Wall of Protest. Everytime I see something like this I grind my teeth. It’s not that I don’t approve of the sentiment, really I do but it seems all so superficial. What are the odds that any anti-gaming legislator is going to read the site and see the pictures and be scared off from a course of advocating strong censorship on videogames as a result? Practically none I’d warrant.

While I believe it’s important not to roll over and ignore rumblings from the legislature I do think it’s naive and somewhat patronising to ‘mobilise gamers’ as though we were some secret underground movement and not for example a multi billion dollar industry with professional lobby groups and very high powered political focus groups. The government isn’t going to take away video games for the same reasons it hasn’t taken away action movies or porn or gangsta rap. The people who make money from it are also the people who are dipping into their pockets for election campaigns. EA or SCEA or Ubisoft or Microsoft independently have enough clout to marginalise the lunatic fringe who pop up in opposition. Collectively they are a huge industrial juggernaut on the same level as Hollywood or Big Tobacco. Nobody who is sane seriously believes that playing video games makes you a monster. Those who profess that they do, are generally making noises to appease a loud minority safe in the knowledge that there is zero chance their proposals will even reach a debate let alone be signed into law. They are playing both sides and we are giving the opposition the validity they need. If we ignore them they will go away.

Frankly the sooner we stop giving column time to uninformed activists (on both sides of the debate) and more time to properly educating the public on how to look after their damn kids then the happier I shall be.



  1. Paul Barnett said,

    I like this post, its ironic as you end up giving space to the people we shouldn’t give space it. I like how you did that. Very English that comedy is.

  2. antipwn said,

    My blog, my rules. Besides, don’t you have a game to make?

  3. Lee Saggers said,

    I was just thinking how Ironic this one is and Paul beats me to it.

    Unfortunately its very true and some guys will use the “games are baaaad mmmkay”, weapon to further thier own aims knowing full well it won’t go anywhere. What can people in the industry do about it? Wish i knew,, then id be laughing it up with a dream mmo job.

    And anyway leave Paul alone, dont YOU have a community to manage.. 😛

    I feel the need to protect him since hes married to my mates, fiance’s sister 😉

  4. Flim said,

    Not meaning to detract from your bit of national pride there Paul, technically we scots (and last I checked the antipwn was born with a kilt) also have a fair whack of irony and self-deprecation in our humour. British if you please 🙂

  5. Lee Saggers said,

    See, you give them free dental and eye care and look where it gets you 😉

  6. Flim said,

    Pah, I’m sure some “list of things invented by scots” somewhere includes eyes and teeth, so shush!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: